Edgemead · Monte Vista · Bothasig

012 546 5996

Practical · 5 min read

Repair or replace: deciding without being sold to

The rule we use ourselves is unglamorous: compare the repair to the replacement, and be honest about what the repair buys.

The half-the-price rule

As a rough guide, if a repair costs more than about half the price of a comparable new unit, replacement usually wins, especially on an appliance more than ten years old. That is not a law, and there are exceptions, but it stops the decision being emotional.

The second question is what the repair buys. A thermostat or a fan motor buys years. A compressor on an old sealed system buys a working appliance with old wiring, an old condenser and an old cabinet, and the next failure is rarely far away.

Age, gas and parts

Older appliances may use refrigerant that is no longer common, which makes a gas repair more expensive and sometimes impossible. Parts availability matters too: a part on a three-week lead time is a different decision from one on the van.

Efficiency is worth including. An appliance from the early 2000s can use substantially more electricity than a current one, so a repair that keeps it alive for five more years is not automatically the cheaper path.

What a good diagnosis looks like

You should be told what failed, how it was tested, what the repair costs and what a replacement would realistically cost. If the answer is only a number, ask for the reason.

We would rather lose the repair and keep the relationship, because most of our work comes from people we have already been to once.

In short

  • Above roughly half the replacement price, replacement usually wins.
  • A compressor repair on an old sealed system rarely pays you back.
  • Ask what was tested and what the repair buys, not just what it costs.
All field notes

Edgemead, Monte Vista & Bothasig

Tell us what is happening in the room.

A call or a WhatsApp message with the symptom and the address is usually enough for us to tell you what kind of visit this is.

CallWhatsApp