Start with the boring things
Check that the plug is firmly in and that the socket is live, especially in a garage where a circuit may have tripped and taken the freezer with it. Look at whether the interior light comes on, and listen for the compressor: a quiet hum means it is trying, silence plus a warm back means it is not running at all, and a click every few minutes followed by silence is a different fault again.
Then check the thermostat and any digital control. A fridge knocked to its coldest setting will run constantly; one knocked to off will not run at all. It sounds trivial, and it is the cheapest possible fix.
Look at the frost pattern
In a freezer, an even layer of frost across the evaporator is a good sign. Frost in one corner only, or a frosted patch with the rest bare, suggests a refrigerant problem: gas is reaching part of the circuit and not the rest. That is a sealed-system repair, not a thermostat.
In a frost-free fridge, ice building at the back of the cabinet usually means the defrost cycle is not completing, a drain is blocked, or the door seal is letting moist air in. Do not chip it out with a knife; you will pierce the evaporator and turn a small fault into an expensive one.
Check the door and the space around it
A sheet of paper closed in the door should be held firmly all the way round. If it slides out easily at one corner, the seal has failed or the hinge has dropped, and the appliance has been running with a permanent leak of warm, moist air.
Also look behind the unit. A fridge pushed hard against a wall in a hot garage, or boxed into joinery with no ventilation, will struggle in exactly the way an underperforming unit does. In the northern suburbs, a garage freezer in December is the classic case.
In short
- Even frost across the evaporator is healthy; a patchy pattern points at refrigerant.
- A seal test with a sheet of paper takes seconds and explains a lot of failures.
- Never chip ice out with a knife, and never let anyone re-gas without finding the leak.