What are you actually storing
A cold room at around 2 to 4 °C suits fresh product you will use within days: meat in a butchery, produce in a deli, dairy in a kitchen. A freezer room at -18 °C or below suits product you buy in bulk and hold, or freeze for later.
The mistake is treating a chiller as a freezer. It will not hold frozen product safely, and pushing the setpoint down simply makes it run continuously and defrost badly.
Holding time and door traffic
Short holding with heavy door traffic needs recovery capacity. Long holding with occasional access needs a well-insulated box and a reliable machine, but tolerates a slower recovery.
That distinction changes the equipment, and it changes the price. A room sized on floor area alone will be wrong in one direction or the other.
Supply, drainage and the envelope
Freezer rooms need heated drains and door frames, a vapour-tight envelope and, usually, more electrical capacity. If the site only has single-phase power, that is a real constraint worth knowing before you commit to a below-zero room.
Where there is not enough space for two rooms, a dual-temperature arrangement is sometimes possible, but it compromises both duties. We would rather build one room that does its job properly.
In short
- Holding time and product decide between chiller and freezer.
- A cold room pushed to freezing temperatures will not perform.
- Freezer rooms need heated drainage and usually more electrical capacity.